Welcome to Sully's GastroPub
Sully's GastroPub, located at 504 Shoup Ave in Idaho Falls, serves up a vibrant dining experience with a diverse menu. This American restaurant excels in comfort food, with a particular focus on burgers and sandwiches, making it a local favorite. The atmosphere strikes a balance between casual and trendy, perfect for enjoying a laid-back meal with friends or family. With a solid selection of local beers and expertly crafted cocktails, this pub transforms tasting into an experience. Offering dine-in, takeaway, and delivery options, Sully's caters to every craving, whether you're grabbing a quick bite or settling in for a leisurely dinner. Friendly service and generous portions have made this spot a crowd-pleaser among tourists and locals alike.
Popular dishes
Restaurant Gallery
About
Idaho Falls has its hidden gems, and Sully's GastroPub proudly fits that bill. Nestled conveniently in the heart of the city, this pub exudes a welcoming vibe. The location is wheelchair-accessible, enhancing the experience for all guests. Upon entering, you’re greeted with a cozy atmosphere complete with comfortable seating and well-curated decor. The pub hosts a mix of locals and tourists, making it an ideal spot for mingling or enjoying solo dining. With ample free parking available, visiting during peak hours doesn’t feel stressful. Despite the bustling crowd at dinnertime—especially on Saturdays—waiting is minimal due to their efficient service. Friendly staff members enhance the pub's charm, ensuring each guest feels valued. Plus, guests can enjoy a game of pool while they wait, making the atmosphere even more lively and engaging.
Working Hours
- SundayOpen
- MondayOpen
- TuesdayOpen
- WednesdayOpen
- ThursdayOpen
- FridayOpen
- SaturdayOpen
What People Say
Most Liked
Dynamic menu options cater to a wide range of palates, with everyone raving about the signature Trashcan sandwich and the Smoked Ribeye French Dip.
The impressive beer and cocktail selection stands out, with locals recommending the unique local brews.
Generous portion sizes ensure you’ll leave satisfied, with many patrons noting they often take food home.
Friendly and attentive service makes every visit enjoyable, with staff genuinely interested in enhancing your dining experience.
The casual, cozy vibe encourages returning guests, fostering a sense of community among regulars.
Weekly trivia nights add an extra layer of excitement and engagement, attracting guests looking to compete and socialize.
Most Disliked
The dinner rush can lead to longer wait times, especially on weekends, which might leave patrons feeling anxious.
Some diners report that certain items can run out, particularly during peak hours, which can be a letdown for eager guests.
Noise levels can climb during busy nights, making it hard for conversations, particularly in the dining area.
Parking can become limited during high traffic periods, challenging guests wanting quick access.
A few visitors wish for more diverse vegetarian options on the menu, although the choices available are still satisfying.
Reviews
Jim J.
Loved this place. Greeted by the hostess who made us feel like she was glad to see us, which is rare these days. All the sandwiches were just as advertised on the menu and everyone in our party was satisfied. Sandwich sizes are very generous. I'm definitely going back.
Cynthia P.
Amazing find in downtown Idaho Falls. The food was SO GOOD! I had a patty melt on marble rye with onion rings. My husband had the Sloppy Josh with fries. Both entrees were so tasty. Our bill was about $40. The ambiance is great: Good music, comfortable seating, and just-right lighting. Service was very attentive and friendly, and everyone was just absolutely beautiful! They really fit in with the pub look, in their style. It was fairly quiet, so the owner came to our table repeatedly to check on us. They even have pool tables to play for their guests to use free of charge. The menu was so full of great options, we'll definitely be back often to try more dishes. Just GO! You will not be sorry. **Update 9/17/25**STILL a 5/5!! We really enjoyed our food and had some much needed fun as a couple playing pool. We ordered their special from Facebook-off the menu, the Mozzarella Explosion burger and the Sour Hen. Both were so, so good! Service is still exceptional! Go treat yourself!
Ryan S.
So this is a place I almost don't want to review because it was so good I want to keep it a secret. Stopped in for lunch yesterday and all I can think about is how good that sandwich was still. Honestly the best sandwich I have had ever period. Such good flavor and everything just went together. And everything on the menu looks amazing. Waitress was awesome super nice and helpful. I went in wanting a patty melt and asked he about the Sully's Trashcan and she gave me that look and told me thats the most popular one and I know why. I can't wait to be back.
Ben M.
The trashcan is a great sandwich. They have some amazing loaf fries appetizers. I heard the burgers were amazing. I recommend Sully’s Gastropub.
April H.
I am in town for a conference and we stumbled across this place. It was FANTASTIC!! I am sure I will be back before leaving town and have told everyone about it. I highly recommend and wish we had one in Ohio!!! Fantastic beer recommendations and the food is amazing!! I barely finished half my food, portion sizes were huge, burger was juicy and full of flavor. Go check it out!!
SUZIE Q.
We showed up shortly after they opened, so it wasn't too busy. Ash was our waitress. She was sweet, helpful and quick to serve our food. The burgers were delicious! Their mozzarella burger special was absolutely incredible! So much CHEESE! Capistrano burger was super good too. The French fires are truly home made and cooked to perfection. We are definitely coming back on our next trip!
Chris R.
Jess was great. The food was amazing. You will spend 20$ but because the burgers are so huge you get two meals. The burger was literally the size of my head
Nearby places to visit
- D'railed 468 N Eastern Ave, Idaho Falls, ID 83402
- BlackRock Fine Wine and Craft Beer 343 Park Ave, Idaho Falls, ID 83402
- A Street Soup Market 445 A St, Idaho Falls, ID 83402
- Don Alberto Mexican Food 900 Pancheri Dr Suite A, Idaho Falls, ID 83402
- Scotty's Drive In 560 Northgate Mile, Idaho Falls, ID 83401